Jack
Bags & Accessories
Feet
Shoes
Socks
Hair, Eyes & Face
Eyes
Face
Hair
Lower Body
Clothing
Upper Body
Clothing
Products

Jill
bags
feet
Head
Face
Hair
Makeup
Skincare
Lower Body
Upper Body

Baby
Accessories, books & toys
Clothing and Skincare
Furniture
Stroller and car seat

Home
bathroom
Bedroom
Deck
Dining Room
Foyer
Garage/Gym
Kitchen
Living Room
Office

Tech
Computer Hardware, Software and Accessories
apps
devices
software
Desk/Office Accessories
Mobile Hardware, Apps and Accessories
apps
devices
software

Wallet
Bank Accounts
Credit Cards
Investment Accounts
Trending Now

Disclaimer: We're not dentists!

got it X
#AmazonPrime#dirtcheap

Best Toothpaste

As of September 2020

Arm & Hammer Advance White Extreme Whitening with Stain Defense

Buy now (2-pack)

Amazon

 Buy now (2-pack)

Walmart

$5.50

THE JOAT'S Advice

The 90-day average price as of 8/31/2020 on Amazon is $5.43, according to data from Keepa. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.

 

Amazon or Walmart are your best bets online. You should also find this locally for a similar price at pretty much every drugstore near you.

Coupons

Please check back later for any personalized JOAT coupons.

Meanwhile, make sure you have the Wikibuy and Honey Chrome extensions installed to automatically find any other existing coupons.

Disclaimer

We may earn affiliate income if you buy products using the links on the site Learn more

what we like

  • Best for those looking for: An effective whitening toothpaste with safe ingredients
  • Best whitening toothpaste that we have tried – It actually works to help restore whiteness to your teeth
  • Does not leave your teeth feeling sensitive
  • Natural and safe based around baking soda as the main ingredient – no sucralose either
  • My mouth feels noticeably cleaner all day when using this vs. typical brands
  • Bottle design is simple and lets you easily get the last bit out of each tube
  • Arm & Hammer guarantees each purchase – Just print out and submit this form if you are unhappy
  • #dirtcheap at under $3/tube

keep in mind

  • You will be thrown off by the taste at first – If you’ve been using traditional Crest/Colgate/Sensodyne gels your whole life, this will taste less sweet and a little saltier (You’ll likely end up preferring it longer-term, but the initial few days are weird)
  • You will be thrown off by the texture at first – It’s definitely grittier and not as smooth as typical gels

review

Most whitening toothpastes I have tried over the years never seemed to work that well. Some left my teeth feeling sensitive while others just didn’t seem to make any type of difference. On recommendation from my dentist, I decided to try this Arm & Hammer one years ago and I have not looked back.

 

The baking soda based blend creates an undeniably unique taste and texture. It certainly takes a few days to get used to after decades of using overly sweet Colgate/Crest gels. But once you turn the corner and adjust to the feeling, it starts to feel like how toothpaste should feel. You end each session feeling truly clean and like your teeth were actually improved a little bit. Within a few weeks I did notice generally whiter teeth as well. At under $3/tube, it also makes for one of the more cost efficient brands on the market. Check with your dentist first to see if this is compatible with your teeth and if so, we think you will be wondering why you didn’t find this sooner.

Sizing Tips & FAQs

What are the ingredients?

Mainly sodium fluoride but it also contains sodium bicarbonate, PEG-8, tetrasodium pyrophosphate, PEG/PPG 116/66 copolymer, sodium carbonate peroxide, silica, sodium saccharin, flavor, water, sodium lauroyl sarcosinate, sodium lauryl sulfate

 

Does it contain sugar or sucralose?

No

 

How long will it take me to notice a difference in my teeth?

I wouldn’t expect some life changing difference at any point, but within a few weeks (assuming you aren’t binge drinking coffee and wine all the time) you should start to see some improvements

 

Does Arm & Hammer do a money back guarantee?

Yes they do. Print out and submit this form after your purchase if you still aren’t satisfied. Just make sure you save the original carton

Have another question?

Related Products & Links

Colgate Optic White Advanced Teeth Whitening Toothpaste

This is another good paste for whitening although it is a bit more expensive. Contains sucralose

 

Crest 3D White Brilliance Vibrant Peppermint Teeth Whitening Toothpaste

Also effective in terms of whitening, but the ingredient list overwhelms Arm & Hammer’s (in a bad way). Contains sucralose too

 

Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Teeth Whitening

For some reason, over the years, Sensodyne has managed to be marketed as the go-to recommendation by dentists. It’s solid and does the job well is almost double the price of Arm & Hammer and does not do as good of a job, in my opinion. The cap and bottle design always seemed to throw me off as well

 

Marvis Toothpaste

I had no idea there was even a such thing as “designer toothpaste” until an ex-girlfriend bought me an entire gift set of these. If you want to stunt on your house guests when they come over to use your guest bathroom, buy one of these as a good #giftsunder$50. Obviously, they aren’t cheap or are recommendation in terms of performance. But they taste good and are fun for travel

Have a better suggestion?

reviewed by

Jack

we also like

×